AN INTERPRETIVE SYNOPSIS OF THE RESTORATION PROPHECIES
An
overview of the prophecies from Isaiah through Malachi presents a collage of
differing conditions surrounding the Restoration of Israel, including Israel’s
proximity to the Promised Land and state of heart at the time of their return.
These differences allow for the possibility of multiple Jewish returns to and dispersions from the Promised Land
over history that fall short of the ultimate glorified restoration prophesied
and for which everyone yearns to this day.
Regenerative
discernment of these differences is vital to accurately perceiving the meaning
of today’s events and avoiding the confusing errors of reconstructionist
interpretation which lead to carnally inflamed passions, dashed expectations
and saints detoured from aligning with God’s real transcendent heart for and
calling on the Jewish people.
If we approach the entire body of restoration prophecy through an end times lens—sifting out historical narrative and prophecy clearly applicable only to the prophet’s immediate experience—we find that the differences in the “restoration collage” break down into two general sets of evidence: one that is clear, dominant and solid; the other tentative, exceptional and sprinkled among the forest of the first.57
- Portrait of Glorious Permanent Restoration
As
a whole, the Old Covenant prophets overwhelmingly paint a bold, dominant
portrait of Israel’s conclusive restoration to the Promised Land from the ends
of the earth. In that portrait, restoration occurs under the following
conditions:
1) in broken repentance laced with trembling (uncertain of being received again by the Lord), but finally reconciled to Yahweh by the New Covenant;58
2)
in
established peace, prosperity and national supremacy;59
3)
with
the unopposed subservient support of the Gentiles under the Lord’s conviction
and also being converted;60
4)
in
permanent joy (with no sorrow), together with the comfort of the Lord;61
5)
in
conjunction with (not anticipation of) Messiah’s return;62
6)
as
a miniscule remnant following a time of world distress which nearly annihilates
the whole planet,63during
which:
a.
that
part of the nation already consolidated
on the Land is attacked in judgment, driven off the Land and destroyed,64
out of which
b.
the
purified preserved remnant is then avenged and those of them dispersed
worldwide return per above.65
These
conditions are articulated over and over among the various prophets. That they
are fulfilled in a glorified regenerative context is verified by key elements
whose witness stretches across the covenants.
·
Repentance: the Key to True
Interpretation of the Restoration
Of
all the above predictions about Israel’s final establishment, one stands out as
the key to their meaning and a bellwether for gauging their fulfillment. It is
the prediction that the Restoration is founded on repentance yielding an inwardly
transformed people.
Because repentance is so basic to the restoration promises, grasping its deep scriptural implications is vital to defining the Spirit’s meaning of restoration and for proving whether Israel’s real restoration has or is occurring. Without an accounting of repentance, evaluations of human events based purely on physical reconstructive evidences of divine activity can only prove deceiving. 66
Whatever
the Spirit means by repentance—its nature, fruits and sequence—will finally
prove to us what restoration truly means and whether what is happening with
natural Israel today truly constitutes the prophesied restoration. Let’s defend
this assertion.
o From Moses to Paul: The Repentance-Restoration Connection
From
first prediction to last, the promise of restoration is tied to repentance.
Moses tells Israel that when they
repent, they will be restored to their land (Dt. 30:1-3ff). At the other end,
the one apostolic teaching on Israel’s restoration (Rom. 9-11), also connects
it to repentance (Rom. 11:26 derives from Isa. 59:20 which inextricably links
Israel’s restoration to Israel’s turning and deliverance from sin.)
The
Mosaic and Pauline promises stand as “bookends” to all the prophecies in
between. Within the bold clear picture, the prophets predicate Israel’s restoration on Israel’s contrite repentance for
their sins. (Isa. 1:25-27; 27:8-9,12-13; 57:13-19; 59:20 w. 60:9-10; Jer. 3:14;
29;12-14; 31:9; 16-21; 50:4-5; Ezk. 6:8-10 w/ 11:16-21; Hos. 3:5; 5:15-6:3;
14:1-7; Joel 2:17-19; Zeph. 3:9-20.) That is the sequence: repentance > restoration.
What
then is the nature of that repentance and its fruit as seen across the
scriptures?
The repentance Moses cites is usually applied only to Israel’s repentance after the Babylonian captivity. True, the Jews expressed a measure of repentance for breaking the Mosaic covenant—at least as articulated by Daniel’s intercession (9:4-19)67
—and subsequently returned from Babylon back to the Land. This is therefore considered to be their restoration.But
compared to the depth and extent of Moses’ promise—and of all the later
prophets— and because God’s call for Israel’s repentance continues right up through Paul, it’s clear that the repentance and
restoration Moses calls for is of a caliber unforeseen in his time, was only superficially fulfilled by the Jews in
BC 538,68
and certainly has not been found among the natural seed at any time since.
o Transformation of the Repentance Call Across the Covenants
Seen
with larger vision, Moses’ call to repentance was but a first call from which grows a vast “repentance thread” leading to
Messiah’s glorious return at the end of the ages.
In between Moses and Paul, Israel’s restoration via repentance is tied to the image of threshing at harvest time from which but a small purged remnant is gleaned.69
The threshing speaks of the tribulation process by which the “chaff” of all that is of the flesh—including racial pride and distinctiveness—is burned away, leaving only the humble to receive Messiah. Such is how John the Immerser finally applies this imagery in his announcement of Yeshua (Mt. 3:7-12).In
this way, the Mosaic call transforms to become the repentance calling forth
eternal life unto new transcendent
identity—the very regenerative
national transformation repentance preached by John, Yeshua and Peter (Acts
2) when they proclaimed the coming of the kingdom. It then ties to Romans 11
where Paul tells of Israel’s restoration through repentance at the end of the
Times of the Gentiles—agreeing with the “harvest time” imagery showing this
occurs at the consummation (“harvest”) of the mortal ages.
All
together then, the call to Israel’s national repentance from Moses through the
prophets to John, Yeshua, Peter and Paul is one
call. Its transformation across the covenants together with its foretold
timing reveals that this repentance is not just a “We’re sorry” for the national forsaking of the Mosaic Law, nor is
it a returning of Israel’s heart to “the Law.”
As
an end time event governed by the New Covenant, Israel’s national repentance is
to be made relative to the New Covenant—the imperishable covenant by which all
men are brought into Eternal Israel. It is to be their repentance for everything at the root of adamic identity
and nature that birthed both their idolatrous forsaking of the Law and
their idolatrous embrace of it unto rejecting Messiah’s superior offer of
regenerative transnational life through faith in Him.
Israel’s
true restoration requires repentance for the self-idolization of human heritage as the “seed of Abraham” by which they
rejected Messiah’s covenantal call to national identity transformation via national self-denial—a covenant whereby
they were to have become the first people ever to forsake their adamic origins (“leaving father and mother”) to be
displayed as members of Eternal Israel from above—and so regeneratively
restored.
When
it occurs, Israel’s repentance will answer to the original intensive repentance
called for by Peter in Acts 2; and will submit to Paul’s teachings of Jewish
heritage denial—something which has yet
to happen even among today’s Messianic believers.
o Like Repentance, Like Restoration
The
nature of true national repentance proves the nature of the Restoration tied to
it and what the restoration prophecies truly are predicting. As the called-for
repentance is ultimately a regenerative one unto eternal life and to national
identity transformation through heritage denial, so is the accompanying
restoration thus proven to be a regenerative one to an entirely new—not
reconstructed—order of glorified life.
On coming to the regenerative repentance climactically exhorted by John, Yeshua and Paul, Israel will undergo the eternal identity change that transforms them corporately to become joined to and manifested as Eternal Israel in the Promised Land.70
Their regeneration coincides with the return of the immortals from ages past who have already put on the identity of Eternal Israel. Israel’s remnant gathering from earth’s “four corners” and Eternal Israel’s gathering from heaven’s “four winds” will be seen as one.71It’s
at this point—together with their
fathers of faith before them and the nationless Gentiles of faith since
Christ—that Israel’s transformed survivors will return to inherit the Promised
Land under all the glorific conditions listed above, decisively showing the
regenerative nature of the Restoration itself.
57 In using an
end time lens, I include consideration of prophecies that clearly had
fulfillment in the first restoration. Because of the regenerative nature of
prophecy, it is unnecessary to discern whether a prophecy “only” referred to
the first restoration from Babylon. Should it be the Spirit meant a prophecy to
strictly refer only to the first restoration without regenerative
consideration, nothing is lost from the overall regenerative case for
interpretation. To the contrary, some things are made clearer.
58 Isa.
27:9; 31:6-7; 41:8-10, 13-14; 49:14; 54:4-6; Jer. 24:7; 29:12-14; 31:9, 16-18,
31-34; 32:38-40; 33:8; 50:4-5, 20; Ezk. 6:8-10; 11:16-20; 16:60-63; 20:39-44;
36:24-29; 36:24-29a, 31; 37:26-27; 39:28-29; Hos. 2:16-17, 19-20; 5:15-6:3;
11:10-11; 14:4; Joel 2:17-18; Zeph. 3:11-13; Zech. 2:12; 3:9; 8:7-8; 10:9;
12:10-14
59 Isa. 11:10-16; 32:18; 41:15-16; 49:8-13; 51:14-16;
54:1-3, 10-17; 55:12-13; 61:4-6, 9; 62:1-12; 65:10; 66:10-14; Jer. 3:14-19;
23:3-8; 24:6; 30:10, 17-18, 20; 31:5, 14, 24-25, 27, 28b, 35-40; 32:37b, 41,
42b-44; 33:6-7,9, 11b-14, 16; 46:27; 51:20-23; Ezk. 17-22-24; 28:24-26;
34:11-16, 25-31; 36:29b-30, 33-35, 37-38; 39:26; Hos. 2:18; 3:5; 14:5-7; Joel
2:19, 21-27; 3:8, 18; Am. 9:11-15; Ob. 18-21; Mic. 4:1-8, 13; 5:7-9; 7:16-17;
Nah. 1:15; Zeph. 2:9-11; 3:13; Hag. 2:7-9; Zech. 1:16-17; 2:4-5; 3:9-10; 8:4-5;
8:12-13, 15; 9:10, 13-17; 10:3-10; 12:6; 14:11, 16-19
60 Isa. 14:1-2; 49:7, 22-23; 60:9-10; Ezk. 36:23-24, 36;
37;28; 39:27; Zeph. 3:9; Zech 2:11; 8:22-23
61 Isa.12:1-3;
14:7; 35:10; 49:15-16; 51:11; 52:8-9; 54:7-8; 61:2-3, 7, 10-11; Jer. 30:19;
31:4,7, 12-13; 33:10-11a; Zech. 2:10
62 Isa.
11:1-4; 31:4; Jer. 23:5-6; 30:9, 21; 33:15, 17; 34;23-24; Ezk. 37:21-25; Hos.
1:10-11; Mic. 2:13; 4:3,6-7; 5:2,4-6; Zech. 6:12-15; 9:10; 14:4-5; Mal. 3:1-2
63
Isa. 1:9-10; 6:11-13;
13:6-13; 17:4-7; 24:20-23; Jer. 25:28-33; Joel 2:30-32; 3:9-15; Ob. 15-17; Mic.
7:13; Zeph. 3:8; Hag. 2:6-7, and
also
supported by the teachings of the Lord and the Book of Revelation
64 Isa. 27:8-11; 29:1-4; 51:17-20; Jer. 30:4-7; 11-15;
31:28a; 32:37a, 42a; 46;28b; Ezk. 11:21; 39:23-24; Am. 9:9-10a; Mic. 4:10a
65 Isa.
1:24-27; 4:3-4; 6:13; 10:12, 20-23; 11:4; 14:4-6; 24-27; 27:12-13; 29:5-7; 31:4-5,
8-9; 35:4; 40:1-2; 9-10; 41:11-12; 49:17,19; 51:22-23; 65:8-9; 66:6-9, 14-24;
Jer. 3:14; 12:14-17; 30:8, 11, 16, 20, 23-24; 31:7-8, 11; 32:37b; 46:28a;
50:18-20, 28, 33-34; 51:9-11, 24; Lam. 4:22a; Ezk. 20:33-38; 28:26; 36:6; Joel
2:20; 3;1-2,7,16,19-21; Am. 9:10b; Mic. 2:12; 4:6-7, 10b-12; Zeph. 2:7,9;
3:8-20; Zech. 2:9; 8:6-8,11; 10:11-12; 12:2-9; 13:8-9; 14:1-3, 12-15; Mal.
3:2-6, 16-18
66 This is true in the same way that Yeshua’s own spiritual activity among Israel 2000 years ago did not of itself restore Israel nor verify His approval of them. It is also true in the same way that spiritual activity can be present in a church today, yet the church finds no favor or standing in God’s site for its inward state. So is it regarding God’s activity among any nation at any time, including Israel today.
67 It’s of great interest that, except for Daniel’s intercessory prayer of repentance, there is no record of any corporate repentance among the Jews in Babylon leading to their release. According to Ezra, the people were simply released by Cyrus to return to Jerusalem. This lack of repentance record lends evidence to support the consideration that Israel’s original return from Babylon did not truly fulfill the Mosaic promise of restoration based on repentance.
68 Significantly, the Jews had hardly returned from Babylon when they were again engaged in the very sins that led to their ejecting in the first place and Ezra had to call them to repentance all over again! See Ezra 9-10.
69 As found, for
example, in Isaiah 17:6; 27:12; 28:23-29; Am. 9:9
70 This will produce the ultimate realization of Paul’s remark,
“What shall their receiving be but life
from the dead?” and of this word, “And
so all Israel shall be saved.” We can
safely believe that, at that time, Paul
himself will have part in teaching surviving mortal Jews in perfecting the
repentance necessary to be joined to the Eternal “Israel of God” and for
realizing participation in the transnational One New Man.
71 This does not mean that natural Israel’s survivors become immediately immortalized; only that the transnational immortal definition of Israel will govern at that time. One challenge in interpreting the restoration prophecies is in realizing that, when their glorified fulfillment is truly realized at Messiah’s return, there will be a diverse mixture of Eternal Israelites and remnant natural Israelites in the land of Israel. Transnational immortals and national mortals pressing toward immortality will be living side by side. The immortals will be realizing their inheritance while the newly saved-by-faith heritage-repentant mortals will be dwelling on the Land conditionally, still seeking immortality and fully revealed membership and inheritance in Eternal Israel.